Uber drivers are workers
The Supreme Court has unanimously upheld an employment tribunal’s decision that Uber drivers are “workers” for the purpose of rights under the National Minimum Wage Act 1998, the Working Time Regulations 1998 and the Employment Rights Act 1996. What are the wider implications of this decision for employers?
Employment v Self-employment
Uber regards its taxi drivers as running their own self-employed businesses and so doesn’t provide them with any employment rights. This was challenged by several drivers who sought to argue before the employment tribunal that they were really “workers” and not self-employed. The employment tribunal, Employment Appeal Tribunal and Court of Appeal all ruled in their favour, so Uber appealed to the Supreme Court, which has now agreed with the lower courts. This means Uber drivers are now entitled to a range of basic employment rights that come with worker status, including paid annual leave and the national minimum wage.
Bigger picture
What is of wider interest here to any employers that engage purportedly self-employed contractors is that in reaching its decision the Supreme Court emphasised that the determination of worker status under employment legislation is a question of statutory interpretation, not one of contractual interpretation, and therefore it’s wrong to treat the written contractual terms as a starting point. If a business uses self-employed contractors, the written contract they’ve put in place to describe them as such isn’t going to count for much if employment status is challenged. What will actually matter is the true nature of the relationship between the business and the individual regardless of the wording of the contract. The greater the control the business exercises over working arrangements and the more the individual is dependent on it, the stronger the case will be for classifying them as a worker.
Related Topics
-
Electronic VAT return and payment due
-
Alternative education providers can protect VAT refund claims
HMRC has confirmed that some alternative providers of higher and further education can submit VAT refund claims following a Court of Appeal ruling, despite HMRC appealing the decision to the Supreme Court. What do you need to know?
-
Old IHT forms will be rejected
HMRC has stopped processing old versions of the Inheritance Tax IHT100 forms from 31 August 2026. Anyone reporting an IHT chargeable event involving a gift or trust will need to make sure they are using the correct forms. What do you need to know?